My Macros+ and AskBeforeYouEat both help you track macronutrients, but they come from different eras of food tracking. My Macros+ is a veteran manual-entry macro tracker built by a fitness professional. AskBeforeYouEat uses AI to let you log meals by photo or plain language. Here's how they compare.
| Feature | AskBeforeYouEat | My Macros+ |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Free forever | Paid (one-time or subscription) |
| AI Photo Recognition | ✓ AI-powered | ✗ Not available |
| Natural Language Logging | ✓ Full support | ✗ Manual entry only |
| Food Database | AI-estimated + growing | 5,000,000+ items |
| Barcode Scanning | Not needed | ✓ + Nutrition label scanner |
| Custom Meal Types | Flexible logging | Unlimited meal types |
| Adaptive Algorithm | ✓ Prime# | ✗ |
| Offline Mode | Requires connection | ✓ Works offline |
| Approach | No-shame, calm | Fitness-focused |
My Macros+ has been around for years, and that longevity shows in its database: over 5 million food items built up over time. For people who eat a lot of packaged foods, that database plus barcode scanning makes logging straightforward — scan the package, confirm the serving size, done.
The app was built by a fitness professional, and it shows in the macro-centric design. Everything revolves around hitting your protein, carb, and fat targets. You can create as many custom meal types as you want (not just the standard breakfast/lunch/dinner/snack), which is helpful for people following specific meal timing protocols.
My Macros+ also works offline, which matters if you travel or have spotty connectivity. And the app is available on iOS, Android, and Apple Watch.
The biggest limitation of My Macros+ in 2026 is that it relies entirely on manual entry. Every meal requires you to search the database, select the right food item, adjust portions, and confirm. For a quick lunch, that might take 30 seconds. For a homemade dinner with eight ingredients? That's several minutes of typing and searching.
There's no AI photo recognition, no natural language input — the tracking paradigm is essentially the same as it was when the app launched. While the database is large, the workflow feels dated compared to apps that let you snap a photo or type "grilled salmon with rice and steamed broccoli" and get an instant estimate.
My Macros+ is also primarily aimed at serious fitness and bodybuilding users. The interface and framing assume you're precisely tracking macros for a performance goal. For people who just want to eat a bit better or understand their patterns without the intensity, the app can feel heavy.
The fundamental difference is input speed. ABYE lets you log meals by taking a photo, typing a natural-language description, or combining both. "A chicken burrito with rice, beans, and sour cream" is a valid entry — no database searching required. For the multi-ingredient meals that make manual trackers tedious, this cuts logging time dramatically.
AskBeforeYouEat is completely free — no one-time purchase, no subscription, no premium tier. Full macro tracking, unlimited logging, AI photo recognition, and the Prime# adaptive algorithm are all included at zero cost with no ads. ABYE is built by TruePrime AI as a public-good nutrition tool.
My Macros+ gives you a static macro target and tracks whether you hit it. ABYE's Prime# algorithm goes further: it learns from your actual eating patterns over time and adapts its insights accordingly. Instead of just showing you numbers against a fixed goal, it helps you understand your habits and how they're evolving.
My Macros+ is built for people who are serious about precision macro tracking — the gym crowd, competitive athletes, bodybuilders. AskBeforeYouEat is built for everyone. The interface is calm, the tone is encouraging, and there's no implicit message that you need to hit exact numbers to succeed. It's awareness, not restriction.
My Macros+ remains a solid choice if you're a dedicated macro tracker who prefers manual control, you eat mostly packaged foods with barcodes, you need offline access, or you've already built years of data in the app. If precision-to-the-gram matters more to you than speed, My Macros+ is purpose-built for that workflow.
ABYE is the better fit if you want:
My Macros+ is a reliable veteran macro tracker for people who want manual control and a massive food database. AskBeforeYouEat brings macro tracking into the AI era — photo recognition, natural language logging, adaptive coaching — and makes it all free. If you want the same macro awareness with less friction and no cost, ABYE is worth trying.
AI photo logging, natural language input, full macro tracking — all free, forever.
Try AskBeforeYouEat Free